r_20261029_190447_1fc8
done- drawing
- drawing.png
- reference
- none
- at
- 2026-10-29T19:04:47Z
Review
If these are right, every cut set is right: the cut sets are computed from the paths and what can fail.
1 · Power reaches the load by these paths
Click a path to light it up on the drawing. Is every part on that route boxed, and nothing extra?
2 · Parts not on the drawing
3 · Assumptions
Opens your email with what you ticked, what you didn't, and your note.
Summary
Single points of failure
No single point of failure: no one component failing on its own cuts the supply.
Pairs
36 pairs: the supply is lost only if both components of a pair fail together.
- {
CB-735-11,CB-735-12} - {
CB-735-11,CT-735-12} - {
CB-735-11,DS-735-12A} - {
CB-735-11,DS-735-12B} - {
CB-735-11,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-735-11,TR-02} - {
CB-735-12,CT-735-11} - {
CB-735-12,DS-735-11A} - {
CB-735-12,DS-735-11B} - {
CB-735-12,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-735-12,TR-01} - {
CT-735-11,CT-735-12} - {
CT-735-11,DS-735-12A} - {
CT-735-11,DS-735-12B} - {
CT-735-11,OE-TR-02} - {
CT-735-11,TR-02} - {
CT-735-12,DS-735-11A} - {
CT-735-12,DS-735-11B} - {
CT-735-12,OE-TR-01} - {
CT-735-12,TR-01} - {
DS-735-11A,DS-735-12A} - {
DS-735-11A,DS-735-12B} - {
DS-735-11A,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-735-11A,TR-02} - {
DS-735-11B,DS-735-12A} - {
DS-735-11B,DS-735-12B} - {
DS-735-11B,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-735-11B,TR-02} - {
DS-735-12A,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-735-12A,TR-01} - {
DS-735-12B,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-735-12B,TR-01} - {
OE-TR-01,OE-TR-02} - {
OE-TR-01,TR-02} - {
OE-TR-02,TR-01} - {
TR-01,TR-02}
Click a set to highlight its components on the drawing and in the block diagram; click it again to clear.
Drawing and graph
Hover a box to see its own connections.
Not on the drawing
| node | type | connected to | why |
|---|---|---|---|
OE-TR-01 | other | DS-735-11B, TR-01 | Spec requires one operating-error block per transformer path. |
OE-TR-02 | other | DS-735-12B, TR-02 | Spec requires one operating-error block per transformer path. |
OE-315-111 | other | DS-315-111A, CB-315-111 | Spec requires one operating-error block per 315 kV branch. |
OE-315-112 | other | DS-315-112A, CB-315-112 | Spec requires one operating-error block per 315 kV branch. |
OE-315-121 | other | DS-315-121A, CB-315-121 | Spec requires one operating-error block per 315 kV branch. |
OE-315-122 | other | DS-315-122A, CB-315-122 | Spec requires one operating-error block per 315 kV branch. |
Cut sets
Reference: none
No verdict: nothing was compared with a reference. These are the model's own cut sets.
This model
Minimal cut sets up to order 3. Click an order to show or hide it.
Order 2 (36)
- {
CB-735-11,CB-735-12} - {
CB-735-11,CT-735-12} - {
CB-735-11,DS-735-12A} - {
CB-735-11,DS-735-12B} - {
CB-735-11,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-735-11,TR-02} - {
CB-735-12,CT-735-11} - {
CB-735-12,DS-735-11A} - {
CB-735-12,DS-735-11B} - {
CB-735-12,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-735-12,TR-01} - {
CT-735-11,CT-735-12} - {
CT-735-11,DS-735-12A} - {
CT-735-11,DS-735-12B} - {
CT-735-11,OE-TR-02} - {
CT-735-11,TR-02} - {
CT-735-12,DS-735-11A} - {
CT-735-12,DS-735-11B} - {
CT-735-12,OE-TR-01} - {
CT-735-12,TR-01} - {
DS-735-11A,DS-735-12A} - {
DS-735-11A,DS-735-12B} - {
DS-735-11A,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-735-11A,TR-02} - {
DS-735-11B,DS-735-12A} - {
DS-735-11B,DS-735-12B} - {
DS-735-11B,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-735-11B,TR-02} - {
DS-735-12A,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-735-12A,TR-01} - {
DS-735-12B,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-735-12B,TR-01} - {
OE-TR-01,OE-TR-02} - {
OE-TR-01,TR-02} - {
OE-TR-02,TR-01} - {
TR-01,TR-02}
Order 3 (300)
- {
CB-315-111,CB-315-112,CB-735-12} - {
CB-315-111,CB-315-112,CT-735-12} - {
CB-315-111,CB-315-112,DS-735-12A} - {
CB-315-111,CB-315-112,DS-735-12B} - {
CB-315-111,CB-315-112,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-315-111,CB-315-112,TR-02} - {
CB-315-111,CB-735-12,CT-315-112} - {
CB-315-111,CB-735-12,DS-315-112A} - {
CB-315-111,CB-735-12,DS-315-112B} - {
CB-315-111,CB-735-12,OE-315-112} - {
CB-315-111,CT-315-112,CT-735-12} - {
CB-315-111,CT-315-112,DS-735-12A} - {
CB-315-111,CT-315-112,DS-735-12B} - {
CB-315-111,CT-315-112,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-315-111,CT-315-112,TR-02} - {
CB-315-111,CT-735-12,DS-315-112A} - {
CB-315-111,CT-735-12,DS-315-112B} - {
CB-315-111,CT-735-12,OE-315-112} - {
CB-315-111,DS-315-112A,DS-735-12A} - {
CB-315-111,DS-315-112A,DS-735-12B} - {
CB-315-111,DS-315-112A,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-315-111,DS-315-112A,TR-02} - {
CB-315-111,DS-315-112B,DS-735-12A} - {
CB-315-111,DS-315-112B,DS-735-12B} - {
CB-315-111,DS-315-112B,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-315-111,DS-315-112B,TR-02} - {
CB-315-111,DS-735-12A,OE-315-112} - {
CB-315-111,DS-735-12B,OE-315-112} - {
CB-315-111,OE-315-112,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-315-111,OE-315-112,TR-02} - {
CB-315-112,CB-735-12,CT-315-111} - {
CB-315-112,CB-735-12,DS-315-111A} - {
CB-315-112,CB-735-12,DS-315-111B} - {
CB-315-112,CB-735-12,OE-315-111} - {
CB-315-112,CT-315-111,CT-735-12} - {
CB-315-112,CT-315-111,DS-735-12A} - {
CB-315-112,CT-315-111,DS-735-12B} - {
CB-315-112,CT-315-111,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-315-112,CT-315-111,TR-02} - {
CB-315-112,CT-735-12,DS-315-111A} - {
CB-315-112,CT-735-12,DS-315-111B} - {
CB-315-112,CT-735-12,OE-315-111} - {
CB-315-112,DS-315-111A,DS-735-12A} - {
CB-315-112,DS-315-111A,DS-735-12B} - {
CB-315-112,DS-315-111A,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-315-112,DS-315-111A,TR-02} - {
CB-315-112,DS-315-111B,DS-735-12A} - {
CB-315-112,DS-315-111B,DS-735-12B} - {
CB-315-112,DS-315-111B,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-315-112,DS-315-111B,TR-02} - {
CB-315-112,DS-735-12A,OE-315-111} - {
CB-315-112,DS-735-12B,OE-315-111} - {
CB-315-112,OE-315-111,OE-TR-02} - {
CB-315-112,OE-315-111,TR-02} - {
CB-315-121,CB-315-122,CB-735-11} - {
CB-315-121,CB-315-122,CT-735-11} - {
CB-315-121,CB-315-122,DS-735-11A} - {
CB-315-121,CB-315-122,DS-735-11B} - {
CB-315-121,CB-315-122,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-315-121,CB-315-122,TR-01} - {
CB-315-121,CB-735-11,CT-315-122} - {
CB-315-121,CB-735-11,DS-315-122A} - {
CB-315-121,CB-735-11,DS-315-122B} - {
CB-315-121,CB-735-11,OE-315-122} - {
CB-315-121,CT-315-122,CT-735-11} - {
CB-315-121,CT-315-122,DS-735-11A} - {
CB-315-121,CT-315-122,DS-735-11B} - {
CB-315-121,CT-315-122,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-315-121,CT-315-122,TR-01} - {
CB-315-121,CT-735-11,DS-315-122A} - {
CB-315-121,CT-735-11,DS-315-122B} - {
CB-315-121,CT-735-11,OE-315-122} - {
CB-315-121,DS-315-122A,DS-735-11A} - {
CB-315-121,DS-315-122A,DS-735-11B} - {
CB-315-121,DS-315-122A,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-315-121,DS-315-122A,TR-01} - {
CB-315-121,DS-315-122B,DS-735-11A} - {
CB-315-121,DS-315-122B,DS-735-11B} - {
CB-315-121,DS-315-122B,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-315-121,DS-315-122B,TR-01} - {
CB-315-121,DS-735-11A,OE-315-122} - {
CB-315-121,DS-735-11B,OE-315-122} - {
CB-315-121,OE-315-122,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-315-121,OE-315-122,TR-01} - {
CB-315-122,CB-735-11,CT-315-121} - {
CB-315-122,CB-735-11,DS-315-121A} - {
CB-315-122,CB-735-11,DS-315-121B} - {
CB-315-122,CB-735-11,OE-315-121} - {
CB-315-122,CT-315-121,CT-735-11} - {
CB-315-122,CT-315-121,DS-735-11A} - {
CB-315-122,CT-315-121,DS-735-11B} - {
CB-315-122,CT-315-121,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-315-122,CT-315-121,TR-01} - {
CB-315-122,CT-735-11,DS-315-121A} - {
CB-315-122,CT-735-11,DS-315-121B} - {
CB-315-122,CT-735-11,OE-315-121} - {
CB-315-122,DS-315-121A,DS-735-11A} - {
CB-315-122,DS-315-121A,DS-735-11B} - {
CB-315-122,DS-315-121A,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-315-122,DS-315-121A,TR-01} - {
CB-315-122,DS-315-121B,DS-735-11A} - {
CB-315-122,DS-315-121B,DS-735-11B} - {
CB-315-122,DS-315-121B,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-315-122,DS-315-121B,TR-01} - {
CB-315-122,DS-735-11A,OE-315-121} - {
CB-315-122,DS-735-11B,OE-315-121} - {
CB-315-122,OE-315-121,OE-TR-01} - {
CB-315-122,OE-315-121,TR-01} - {
CB-735-11,CT-315-121,CT-315-122} - {
CB-735-11,CT-315-121,DS-315-122A} - {
CB-735-11,CT-315-121,DS-315-122B} - {
CB-735-11,CT-315-121,OE-315-122} - {
CB-735-11,CT-315-122,DS-315-121A} - {
CB-735-11,CT-315-122,DS-315-121B} - {
CB-735-11,CT-315-122,OE-315-121} - {
CB-735-11,DS-315-121A,DS-315-122A} - {
CB-735-11,DS-315-121A,DS-315-122B} - {
CB-735-11,DS-315-121A,OE-315-122} - {
CB-735-11,DS-315-121B,DS-315-122A} - {
CB-735-11,DS-315-121B,DS-315-122B} - {
CB-735-11,DS-315-121B,OE-315-122} - {
CB-735-11,DS-315-122A,OE-315-121} - {
CB-735-11,DS-315-122B,OE-315-121} - {
CB-735-11,OE-315-121,OE-315-122} - {
CB-735-12,CT-315-111,CT-315-112} - {
CB-735-12,CT-315-111,DS-315-112A} - {
CB-735-12,CT-315-111,DS-315-112B} - {
CB-735-12,CT-315-111,OE-315-112} - {
CB-735-12,CT-315-112,DS-315-111A} - {
CB-735-12,CT-315-112,DS-315-111B} - {
CB-735-12,CT-315-112,OE-315-111} - {
CB-735-12,DS-315-111A,DS-315-112A} - {
CB-735-12,DS-315-111A,DS-315-112B} - {
CB-735-12,DS-315-111A,OE-315-112} - {
CB-735-12,DS-315-111B,DS-315-112A} - {
CB-735-12,DS-315-111B,DS-315-112B} - {
CB-735-12,DS-315-111B,OE-315-112} - {
CB-735-12,DS-315-112A,OE-315-111} - {
CB-735-12,DS-315-112B,OE-315-111} - {
CB-735-12,OE-315-111,OE-315-112} - {
CT-315-111,CT-315-112,CT-735-12} - {
CT-315-111,CT-315-112,DS-735-12A} - {
CT-315-111,CT-315-112,DS-735-12B} - {
CT-315-111,CT-315-112,OE-TR-02} - {
CT-315-111,CT-315-112,TR-02} - {
CT-315-111,CT-735-12,DS-315-112A} - {
CT-315-111,CT-735-12,DS-315-112B} - {
CT-315-111,CT-735-12,OE-315-112} - {
CT-315-111,DS-315-112A,DS-735-12A} - {
CT-315-111,DS-315-112A,DS-735-12B} - {
CT-315-111,DS-315-112A,OE-TR-02} - {
CT-315-111,DS-315-112A,TR-02} - {
CT-315-111,DS-315-112B,DS-735-12A} - {
CT-315-111,DS-315-112B,DS-735-12B} - {
CT-315-111,DS-315-112B,OE-TR-02} - {
CT-315-111,DS-315-112B,TR-02} - {
CT-315-111,DS-735-12A,OE-315-112} - {
CT-315-111,DS-735-12B,OE-315-112} - {
CT-315-111,OE-315-112,OE-TR-02} - {
CT-315-111,OE-315-112,TR-02} - {
CT-315-112,CT-735-12,DS-315-111A} - {
CT-315-112,CT-735-12,DS-315-111B} - {
CT-315-112,CT-735-12,OE-315-111} - {
CT-315-112,DS-315-111A,DS-735-12A} - {
CT-315-112,DS-315-111A,DS-735-12B} - {
CT-315-112,DS-315-111A,OE-TR-02} - {
CT-315-112,DS-315-111A,TR-02} - {
CT-315-112,DS-315-111B,DS-735-12A} - {
CT-315-112,DS-315-111B,DS-735-12B} - {
CT-315-112,DS-315-111B,OE-TR-02} - {
CT-315-112,DS-315-111B,TR-02} - {
CT-315-112,DS-735-12A,OE-315-111} - {
CT-315-112,DS-735-12B,OE-315-111} - {
CT-315-112,OE-315-111,OE-TR-02} - {
CT-315-112,OE-315-111,TR-02} - {
CT-315-121,CT-315-122,CT-735-11} - {
CT-315-121,CT-315-122,DS-735-11A} - {
CT-315-121,CT-315-122,DS-735-11B} - {
CT-315-121,CT-315-122,OE-TR-01} - {
CT-315-121,CT-315-122,TR-01} - {
CT-315-121,CT-735-11,DS-315-122A} - {
CT-315-121,CT-735-11,DS-315-122B} - {
CT-315-121,CT-735-11,OE-315-122} - {
CT-315-121,DS-315-122A,DS-735-11A} - {
CT-315-121,DS-315-122A,DS-735-11B} - {
CT-315-121,DS-315-122A,OE-TR-01} - {
CT-315-121,DS-315-122A,TR-01} - {
CT-315-121,DS-315-122B,DS-735-11A} - {
CT-315-121,DS-315-122B,DS-735-11B} - {
CT-315-121,DS-315-122B,OE-TR-01} - {
CT-315-121,DS-315-122B,TR-01} - {
CT-315-121,DS-735-11A,OE-315-122} - {
CT-315-121,DS-735-11B,OE-315-122} - {
CT-315-121,OE-315-122,OE-TR-01} - {
CT-315-121,OE-315-122,TR-01} - {
CT-315-122,CT-735-11,DS-315-121A} - {
CT-315-122,CT-735-11,DS-315-121B} - {
CT-315-122,CT-735-11,OE-315-121} - {
CT-315-122,DS-315-121A,DS-735-11A} - {
CT-315-122,DS-315-121A,DS-735-11B} - {
CT-315-122,DS-315-121A,OE-TR-01} - {
CT-315-122,DS-315-121A,TR-01} - {
CT-315-122,DS-315-121B,DS-735-11A} - {
CT-315-122,DS-315-121B,DS-735-11B} - {
CT-315-122,DS-315-121B,OE-TR-01} - {
CT-315-122,DS-315-121B,TR-01} - {
CT-315-122,DS-735-11A,OE-315-121} - {
CT-315-122,DS-735-11B,OE-315-121} - {
CT-315-122,OE-315-121,OE-TR-01} - {
CT-315-122,OE-315-121,TR-01} - {
CT-735-11,DS-315-121A,DS-315-122A} - {
CT-735-11,DS-315-121A,DS-315-122B} - {
CT-735-11,DS-315-121A,OE-315-122} - {
CT-735-11,DS-315-121B,DS-315-122A} - {
CT-735-11,DS-315-121B,DS-315-122B} - {
CT-735-11,DS-315-121B,OE-315-122} - {
CT-735-11,DS-315-122A,OE-315-121} - {
CT-735-11,DS-315-122B,OE-315-121} - {
CT-735-11,OE-315-121,OE-315-122} - {
CT-735-12,DS-315-111A,DS-315-112A} - {
CT-735-12,DS-315-111A,DS-315-112B} - {
CT-735-12,DS-315-111A,OE-315-112} - {
CT-735-12,DS-315-111B,DS-315-112A} - {
CT-735-12,DS-315-111B,DS-315-112B} - {
CT-735-12,DS-315-111B,OE-315-112} - {
CT-735-12,DS-315-112A,OE-315-111} - {
CT-735-12,DS-315-112B,OE-315-111} - {
CT-735-12,OE-315-111,OE-315-112} - {
DS-315-111A,DS-315-112A,DS-735-12A} - {
DS-315-111A,DS-315-112A,DS-735-12B} - {
DS-315-111A,DS-315-112A,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-315-111A,DS-315-112A,TR-02} - {
DS-315-111A,DS-315-112B,DS-735-12A} - {
DS-315-111A,DS-315-112B,DS-735-12B} - {
DS-315-111A,DS-315-112B,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-315-111A,DS-315-112B,TR-02} - {
DS-315-111A,DS-735-12A,OE-315-112} - {
DS-315-111A,DS-735-12B,OE-315-112} - {
DS-315-111A,OE-315-112,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-315-111A,OE-315-112,TR-02} - {
DS-315-111B,DS-315-112A,DS-735-12A} - {
DS-315-111B,DS-315-112A,DS-735-12B} - {
DS-315-111B,DS-315-112A,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-315-111B,DS-315-112A,TR-02} - {
DS-315-111B,DS-315-112B,DS-735-12A} - {
DS-315-111B,DS-315-112B,DS-735-12B} - {
DS-315-111B,DS-315-112B,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-315-111B,DS-315-112B,TR-02} - {
DS-315-111B,DS-735-12A,OE-315-112} - {
DS-315-111B,DS-735-12B,OE-315-112} - {
DS-315-111B,OE-315-112,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-315-111B,OE-315-112,TR-02} - {
DS-315-112A,DS-735-12A,OE-315-111} - {
DS-315-112A,DS-735-12B,OE-315-111} - {
DS-315-112A,OE-315-111,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-315-112A,OE-315-111,TR-02} - {
DS-315-112B,DS-735-12A,OE-315-111} - {
DS-315-112B,DS-735-12B,OE-315-111} - {
DS-315-112B,OE-315-111,OE-TR-02} - {
DS-315-112B,OE-315-111,TR-02} - {
DS-315-121A,DS-315-122A,DS-735-11A} - {
DS-315-121A,DS-315-122A,DS-735-11B} - {
DS-315-121A,DS-315-122A,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-315-121A,DS-315-122A,TR-01} - {
DS-315-121A,DS-315-122B,DS-735-11A} - {
DS-315-121A,DS-315-122B,DS-735-11B} - {
DS-315-121A,DS-315-122B,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-315-121A,DS-315-122B,TR-01} - {
DS-315-121A,DS-735-11A,OE-315-122} - {
DS-315-121A,DS-735-11B,OE-315-122} - {
DS-315-121A,OE-315-122,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-315-121A,OE-315-122,TR-01} - {
DS-315-121B,DS-315-122A,DS-735-11A} - {
DS-315-121B,DS-315-122A,DS-735-11B} - {
DS-315-121B,DS-315-122A,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-315-121B,DS-315-122A,TR-01} - {
DS-315-121B,DS-315-122B,DS-735-11A} - {
DS-315-121B,DS-315-122B,DS-735-11B} - {
DS-315-121B,DS-315-122B,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-315-121B,DS-315-122B,TR-01} - {
DS-315-121B,DS-735-11A,OE-315-122} - {
DS-315-121B,DS-735-11B,OE-315-122} - {
DS-315-121B,OE-315-122,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-315-121B,OE-315-122,TR-01} - {
DS-315-122A,DS-735-11A,OE-315-121} - {
DS-315-122A,DS-735-11B,OE-315-121} - {
DS-315-122A,OE-315-121,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-315-122A,OE-315-121,TR-01} - {
DS-315-122B,DS-735-11A,OE-315-121} - {
DS-315-122B,DS-735-11B,OE-315-121} - {
DS-315-122B,OE-315-121,OE-TR-01} - {
DS-315-122B,OE-315-121,TR-01} - {
DS-735-11A,OE-315-121,OE-315-122} - {
DS-735-11B,OE-315-121,OE-315-122} - {
DS-735-12A,OE-315-111,OE-315-112} - {
DS-735-12B,OE-315-111,OE-315-112} - {
OE-315-111,OE-315-112,OE-TR-02} - {
OE-315-111,OE-315-112,TR-02} - {
OE-315-121,OE-315-122,OE-TR-01} - {
OE-315-121,OE-315-122,TR-01}
Gaps
315kV-NETWORK (sink)The spec doesn't set the sink. I used a virtual node fed from both 315 kV buses, so supply to either bus counts as success. If the study needs a particular bus (or both buses) supplied, the cut sets will change.OE-* operating-error blocksThe drawing doesn't show operating-error blocks. Following the spec, I put one in series in each transformer path (OE-TR-01/02) and one in each 315 kV branch (OE-315-111/112/121/122). Each is independent, and their exact place in the series chain doesn't affect the cut sets.
Assumptions
Scope: Everything inside the dashed boundary: BUS 735, two 735 kV transformer bays (DS/CB/CT/DS + TR), four 315 kV bays, BUS 315-A and BUS 315-B, plus the operating-error blocks.. Spec says the scope is the dashed study boundary.
Boundary: Source = 735 kV lines arriving at BUS 735. Sink = a single virtual node for the 315 kV network, fed from both BUS 315-A and BUS 315-B.. The drawing marks the 735 kV lines as the source and both 315 kV buses as outgoing to the 315 kV network. Under any-path success, supply reaching either 315 kV bus counts.
Can fail: breaker, disconnector, ct, transformer, other. Spec: breakers, disconnectors, CTs and power transformers can fail; 'other' holds the operating-error blocks the spec requires. Busbars, source and sink are perfect connectors.
Success: any_path. Spec: any one source-to-sink path is enough.
Not modelled:
- 735 kV lines and the 315 kV network beyond the buses: They are outside the dashed study boundary.
- Protection, control, auxiliary systems, capacity limits (N-1 loading): Note 4 says they are not shown; the any-path rule ignores capacity.
- Common-mode and maintenance outages: The spec doesn't ask for them.